By Jacob Gordon, Esq. | Former Insurance Defense Attorney | Tampa Personal Injury Lawyer
Most people who file a personal injury claim in Florida have no idea how thoroughly the insurance company is investigating them. They assume the process is straightforward: you file a claim, the insurance company reviews it, and they pay you. But having spent years representing insurance companies, I can tell you that the investigation process is far more aggressive than most claimants realize.
Understanding what’s happening behind the scenes isn’t about being paranoid. It’s about being prepared. If you know what the insurance company is looking for, you can avoid the mistakes that give them ammunition to deny or devalue your claim.
The Claims File: Your Case Has a Dossier
The moment you file a claim, the insurance company opens what’s called a claims file. This is a comprehensive record that tracks every aspect of your case. When I was in defense work, I regularly reviewed claims files that were hundreds of pages long — and the claimant had no idea most of that information existed.
The claims file typically includes the police report, your initial statement to the adjuster, all medical records the insurer has obtained, notes from every phone conversation you’ve had with the adjuster, photographs of the accident scene and vehicles, and any social media content they’ve collected. Everything you say or do from the moment of the accident forward is potentially going into this file.
Surveillance: Yes, They Really Do Watch You
This surprises many of my clients, but it shouldn’t: insurance companies routinely hire private investigators to conduct physical surveillance of claimants. This is especially common in cases involving claims of serious or permanent injury.
During my defense career, I worked with surveillance footage in numerous cases. Investigators will follow you to the grocery store, film you at your child’s soccer game, and record you doing yard work. They’re looking for any activity that appears inconsistent with your claimed injuries. If you’ve told your doctor you can’t bend at the waist, but the investigator catches you on video picking up a bag of mulch, that footage will be devastating to your case.
The important thing to understand is that surveillance can be misleading. We all have good days and bad days with injuries. The fact that you managed to walk to your mailbox on Tuesday doesn’t mean you weren’t in debilitating pain on Monday and Wednesday. But a thirty-second video clip doesn’t show context — and insurance companies know how to present those clips in the most damaging way possible.
The Medical Records Deep Dive
When you file a personal injury claim, you typically sign a medical authorization allowing the insurance company to obtain your medical records related to the accident. But here’s what many people don’t realize: insurers will often try to obtain your complete medical history, going back years or even decades.
They’re looking for pre-existing conditions, prior complaints of similar symptoms, previous injury claims, and anything else they can use to argue that your current problems predate the accident. I spent a significant portion of my defense career combing through medical records looking for exactly these things. A notation from a doctor’s visit five years ago where you mentioned occasional back stiffness could become the centerpiece of the defense strategy in your current herniated disc case.
This is why it’s critical to be completely honest with your attorney about your medical history. If there are prior issues, we need to know about them so we can address them proactively rather than being ambushed by them later.
The Independent Medical Examination (That Isn’t Independent)
At some point in many personal injury cases, the insurance company will request that you attend an “independent medical examination” or IME. The name suggests an objective, neutral evaluation. The reality is different.
IME doctors are selected and paid by the insurance company. Many of them perform dozens or hundreds of IMEs per year for the same insurers. The financial incentive structure is worth understanding as it creates inherent bias.
The IME doctor’s report will often conclude that your injuries are less severe than your treating physician believes, that you’ve reached maximum medical improvement sooner than expected, or that your condition is related to pre-existing factors rather than the accident. This report then becomes a key piece of evidence the insurance company uses to justify a lower settlement offer — or a denial.
If you’re asked to attend an IME, talk to your attorney first. There are strategies for preparing, and there are limits on what the insurance company can require.
How to Protect Yourself During the Investigation
Knowing how the investigation works gives you a significant advantage. Here’s what I recommend based on my experience on both sides:
Be consistent and honest. Be truthful with your doctors about your symptoms, your limitations, and your medical history. Inconsistencies between what you tell different doctors — or between what you say and what the surveillance shows — are the easiest points of attack for the insurance company.
Follow your treatment plan. Don’t skip appointments. Don’t stop treatment early because you’re feeling a little better. Gaps in treatment are one of the first things adjusters look for, because they suggest your injuries aren’t as serious as claimed.
Be mindful of your activities. Assume you could be filmed at any time. That doesn’t mean you should stay in bed — it means you should be aware that your activities may be observed and potentially taken out of context.
Work closely with your lawyer. Your attorney can guide you on what authorizations to sign, how to handle IME requests, and how to avoid common pitfalls that the insurance company is hoping you’ll fall into.
The investigation process is designed to find weaknesses in your claim. An experienced personal injury attorney who understands these tactics — because they used to deploy them — can help you navigate the process without falling into the traps.
———
Contact Jacob Gordon Law for a free consultation.
jacobgordonlaw.com